Rotten Taste Already for “Cutthroat Kitchen” Food Show

By Edward M.  Bury, APR (aka The PRDude)

Tonight, The Food Network, which has given the culinary curious some pretty good shows like Chopped and Iron Chef America,, will debut a new one: Cutthroat Kitchen.

Is this the kind of contestant that will appear on Cutthroat Kitchen?

Is this the kind of contestant that will appear on Cutthroat Kitchen?

Since chefs frequently wield sharp knives, I first thought this show would be something akin to The Ultimate Fighter kind of competition, only by tattooed people who can produce decent veal stock and can define the Maillard reaction.  After seeing TV promos and reading more, I stand corrected.

Hosted by Alton Brown, the program, according a web posting, is structured around “the element of a game — one that includes sabotage, scheming and backstabbing.”  (I trust the “backstabbing” part does not involve a 10-inch chef’s knife.)   There’s more:  each of the four contestants received $25,000, “money that can either be kept as a potential prize or used toward sabotage and the purchase of items/challenges.”

This concept has all the appeal of a rotten egg on burnt toast served with stale, cold coffee in a cracked cup.

Here’s why. The entire “food/foodie/celebrity chef” phenomenon has evolved — make the “devolved” — food programming into “competitions” designed to incite, appeal to the lowest common denominator and show a disregard for precious food and the skills, dedication and work required to prepare food for consumption.

Cutthroat Kitchen, which I don’t plan to watch even out of morbid curiosity, is just one of a seemingly increasing number programs that reflect poorly on the culinary arts and those who call themselves chefs.  I can learn something from a show like Chopped, like how to combine ingredients that don’t make sense into something that tastes good.

Wouldn't you rather watch and learn from this chef?

Wouldn’t you rather watch and learn from this chef?

What will I learn from Cutthroat Kitchen?  How to steal someone’s butter and ruin his or her souffle?

Too much attention is given to recent prime time food programming that goes beyond cooking and slides into headlong into unadulterated snark. True, there are still many “how to” food programs aired these days, but few in the evenings.   Read this 2011 post for my thoughts on two entertaining TV chefs who made an impression on me years before chefs held celebrity status.

Perhaps the minds at The Food Network and other networks will take the initiative to produce a program based on Take Part, a movement where eight great chefs work to end hunger in America.

In its essence, food is all about addressing hunger, is it not? And, it’s tremendous that many today take pleasure in cooking.  After all, Julia Child did not write “The Displeasure of Cooking.”

About these ads

9 thoughts on “Rotten Taste Already for “Cutthroat Kitchen” Food Show

  1. I disagree that this show reflects poorly on the culinary profession. If anything, it just reflects poorly on the already pretty tarnished reputation of The Food Network.

    The reason is that any interest group, as its audience grows, begins being comprised less and less of the authentic, earnest people who founded it, and accumulates hangers-on and lesser personalities like a snowball rolling downhill.

    But it’s not guilt by association. It’s not a slippery slope. The core of the culinary arts are still what they’ve always been. There’s just a bunch of extra dirty snow around the edges.

    • Hello: Thanks for your comment. Perhaps my contention is part of something bigger: Are we primarily interested these days only in confrontation and not civil discourse?

      EMB

      • We are not a single entity. As a society, our wants and interests are numerous. Some people want quality food-related content. Others just want reality tv fighting and carnage, and almost any piece of window-dressing around it will do. The key is in identifying which shows cater to your interests and disregarding the rest.

  2. Agreed. People flock to “Real Housewives” shows and the one that followed the antics of drunken young adults cavorting in a beach house. I admit to having watched “The Osbourne’s” once or twice.

  3. When they made the shows about stupid chef tricks, they destroyed them. This season of Top Chef Masters is a disaster for that reason, and Iron Chef America is on a steep decline. I won’t watch this show. It’s *all* stupid chef tricks. Alton Brown used to have some integrity. What happened to him?

    Oddly enough, one of the few shows that’s about creativity, cleverness, grace under fire, and cooking is Chopped. That’s still watchable.

    • Thanks for your thoughts and I agree wholeheartedly. I know these shows are more about entertainment and drama than food. Perhaps some day they’ll run out of dumb ideas and get back to cooking challenges that are absent of carnival trappings. As for Mr. Brown: He saw green, not in lettuce or English peas, but U.S. Currency.

    • I totally agree. Way too many “competition” type shows on every channel. I expect better from the Food Network. Sadly it is sinking lower and lower in my opinion.

      • Hi: Thanks for your comment. Perhaps the snarky competition shows will diminish and we’ll see more programming on food preparation, safety and nutrition. EMBury

  4. Pingback: Prdude's Blog | Perhaps Not as Historic as The Beatles’ 50th Anniversary …

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s